HomeMy WebLinkAboutITEM II-A
~K
~ DRAFT
PLANNING COMMISSION
~ WASHINGTC?N OCTOBER 6, 2009
MINUTES
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Judi Roland called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers
located on the first floor of Auburn City Hall, 25 West Main Street, Auburn, WA.
Commission Members present were: Chair Judi Roland, Vice Chair Kevin Chapman,
Bob Baggett, Ron Copple, Peter Di Turi, Michael Hamilton, Joan Mason and Dave
Peace. Staff present included: Assistant Director Kevin Snyder, Principal Planner Elizabeth
Chamberlain, Storm Drainage Engineer Tim Carlaw, Sewer Utility Engineer Bob Elwell,
Transportation Planner Tiffin Goodman, and Planning Secretary Renee Tobias.
Audience members present included: Robert C. Donihue, Anita Donihue, David Green,
Ray Keasey, Denny Holt and Hans Korve.
II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Commissioner DitTuri moved and Commissioner Hamilton seconded to approve the
minutes of the September 9, 2009 meeting as submitted.
The motion passed unanimously 8-0.
III. PUBLIC COMMENT
There were no public comments.
IV. PLANNING DEPARTMENT REPORT
Principal Planner Elizabeth Chamberlain updated the commission on the downtown
projects. The hospital parking and medical office are almost complete with the final
inspection taking place in few days. Tenant improvement applications for the medical
office have been received for an oncology center, linear accelerator center and a
neurology center. The City will occupy the second floor and a portion of the third floor of
the Auburn Professional Plaza which has been renamed to One Main Street. Tenants
on the first floor include Key Bank, Valley Women's Clinic and a sleep disorder center
with internal medicine.
Mel's Lumber and Hardware building, at the corner of 1St Street NW and A Street NW,
was demolished this week. It will be a temporary surface parking lot to serve as the
required parking for One Main Street building. The property will be redeveloped
sometime in the future.
Staff is working with the Alpert International team on the Auburn Junction project. The
Downtown Redevelopment Committee will discuss the City Hall Plaza at their October
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
13, 2009 meeting, and how that might be incorporated and potentially expanded south of
Main Street. The City has submitted a$3 million Economic Development Administration
grant for the Promenade Project which includes widening the sidewalk and upgrading
utility systems for future downtown development.
Assistant Director Kevin Snyder stated that the Ciry Council took positive action, with
minor changes, on the amendments to the city code Chapter 18.56 Temporary Uses and
Chapter 18 Administrative Use Permits & Conditional use Permits. The City Council
asked staff to express their appreciation to the Commission for their hard work on the
code update project and willingness to collaborate with Planning & Community
Development Committee. The next code amendments will come before the Commission
in the near future.
- V. PUBLIC HEARINGS
Chair Roland requested that the private-initiated Comprehensive Plan Amendments be
presented first.
Principal Planner Elizabeth Chamberlain presented a briefing on the process for the
City's Comprehensive Plan utilizing a PowerPoint presentation. Amendments can be
initiated by the City of Auburn (city-initiated) and by private citizens (privately-initiated).
The requests are reviewed in a public hearing before the Planning Commission, who
makes a recommendation to the City Council. Staff will take the Commission's
recommendation to Council committees and then to full council for their review and
action. It is anticipated that these will go before the City Council January 2010.
B. CPA09-0002 Lvden and Lvden Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Applicant: George Lyden and Charles Lyden
Agent: Dennis Holt, Holt and Associates, Inc.
Chair Roland opened the Public Hearing at 7:08 p.m. to receive comments on -
CPA09-0002 Lyden and Lyden Comprehensive Plan Amendment.
Principal Planner Elizabeth Chamberlain provided an overview of the CPM #5 map
which was included in the agenda packet. This Comprehensive Plan map
amendment request is to change the land use designation of a 4.45 acre parcel from
Light Commercial to Light Industrial. Staff reviewed the current Comprehensive Plan
designation, zoning designation and land uses of the site and surrounding
properties.
Staff distributed a copy of the Auburn North Business Area Plan Policies and a page
from the Economic Development Strategies that encompass the Lyden property.
The property is within the Auburn North Business Area Plan (ANBAP), which states
' that this area should include light commercial and high density residential with uses
that complement the Downtown area such as entertainment, professional office,
dining, medical/dental, or personal services (Policy AN1.1). The majority of the
ANBAP area shall be general commercial (also known as Light Commercial) with the
exception of the Fred Meyer parcel, and shall remain Heavy Commercial (Policy
AN1.7). The implementing zone shall be C-1, Light Commercial (Policy AN1.8).
Page 3
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
Surrounding land uses are light commercial and heavy commercial in nature. A
change to Light Industrial will create an incompatible use with the senior assisted
living to the east, Lowe's to the north, and the vacant site owned by Multicare that
could potentially be a large medical facility. The proposed change to Light Industrial
is also incompatible with the uses envisioned for the area in the ANBAP.
The subject property is part of the major redevelopment area identified in the
Economic Development Strategies document for a range of uses as stated before.
This area will be connected to Downtown Auburn through the construction of the A
Street link (A/B Street Corridor) and will be an extension of downtown.
Staff recommends that the Planning Commission recommend to the City Council
denial of Lyden and Lyden Comprehensive Plan Amendment.
In response to Commission's question, staff reviewed A/B Street Corridor map,
stating that the road does come into the Lyden property. Directly south of the subject
property is wetlands and one property further south is where Mohawk will expand
across A Street. Staff clarified that the CPM #5 Staff Analysis included in the agenda
packet should read that the request is to change the land designation from Light
Commercial to Light Industrial.
Dennis Holt Holt & Associates 1215 S. Central Avenue #211 Kent WA 98032
Mr. Holt stated that the property has been in the Lyden Family for a number of years.
Mr. Holt provided a historical background on the property and area. Mr. Holt
distributed a map that elaborated on the map that was included in the Staff Report.
Mr. Holt stated that 50% of the subject property is wetlands in the northern section.
Further, properties to the north and east also contain 50% wetlands. Mr. Holt agrees
with the City's stance that C-1 Light Commercial property should be preserved but
doesn't feel that this property should be included in the preservation due to its small
size.
In response to Commission's question, Mr. Holt stated that there are no concrete
uses planned for the property. It was noted that the Peterson Cheese Company
looked at expanding to this property but felt it was too small to develop. The owner's
of the subject property support the City's planned capital improvement for the area
and will cooperate with efforts to see them realized as appropriate user demands for
the subject site evolve.
There being no one present to speak regarding the CPM #5, Chair Roland closed the public
hearing at 7:32 p.m.
Commission asked if there is a City wetlands map that confirms Mr. Holt's diagram of
wetlands and mitigation areas. Staff responded that the Mr. Holt's diagram is a fairly
close image of what the wetlands are within the vicinity. Ms. Chamberlain referred
the Commissioners to the property's grading site plan that was included in the
application within the binder.
Staff confirmed that the subject property would have frontage along the A/B Street
Corridor. Staff concurred that currently the subject project is slightly isolated being
Page 4
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
surrounded by wetlands and railroads to the west. However, with the construction of
the A/B Street Corridor it wiii no longer be an isolated piece property. The A/B Street
Corridor wiil connect into the downtown area and further north of the subject
property. Staff reported that the City is working on the funding to complete the A/B
Street Corridor and staff is working on the environmental stage right now. It is
estimated that the Corridor would be fully constructed within the next few years.
Staff confirmed Commission's question and statement that there are traffic pattern
differences between Light Commercial (more automobile traffic during peak hours)
and Light Industrial (heavy truck traffic).
Commission asked Mr. Holt if the completion of the A/B Street Corridor would assist
with the commercial marketability and increase the value of the subject property. Mr.
Holt agreed and also believes that it would be a busy traffic corridor. However, even
with the completion of the A/B Street Corridor, Mr. Holt stated that their discussions
with commercial realtors indicate that the property would still not be attractive to
commercial users.
Commissioner DiTuri moved and Commissioner Mason seconded to recommend
approval of the Lyden and Lyden Comprehensive Plan Amendment, CPM #5, to City
Council.
MOTION CARRIED 7-1. Commissioner Hamilton voted no.
C. CPA09-0004 Craiq Commercial
Applicant: Jacob Amy
Agent: Hans Korve, DMP, Inc.
Chair Roland opened the Public Hearing at 7:51 p.m. to receive comments on
CPA09-0004 Craig Commercial Comprehensive Plan Amendment.
Principal Planner Elizabeth Chamberlain provided an overview of the CPM #6 map
utilizing a PowerPoint presentation; this map was included in the agenda packet.
This comprehensive plan map amendment request is to change the land use
designation of a.3 acre (13,068 square feet) parcel from High Density Residential to
Heavy Commercial (Parcel No. 5125400241). Staff reviewed the current
Comprehensive Plan designation, zoning designation and land uses of the site and
surrounding properties.
The subject site is conducive to multi-family development and the future proposal of
townhomes is compatible with the surrounding land uses. Under the High Density
Residential land use designation and implementing zone of R-20 (Residential 20
du/acre), the site could yield six units. Under the Heavy Commercial land use
designation and implementing zone of C-3, Heavy Commercial, the site could yield
eleven units (approximate density 36 du/acre). The applicant would like to develop
the site as multifamily but wants to achieve a higher density through a commercial
designation.
Page 5
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
Policy LU-34 states that multiple-family developments should be located functionally
convenient to the necessary supporting facilities including utilities, arterials, parks,
transit service, etc. The property meets the policies for High Density Residential
development; however the applicanYs proposal to achieve more units cannot be
realized with the current land use or zoning of R-20. Staff supports higher density on
this site as commercial services are available along Auburn Way North, a middle
school is within walking distance, and transit is available less than a quarter mile
from the subject site. However, staff does not support a change to Heavy
Commercial as the method to achieve higher density.
Staff recommends denial of the Craig Commercial Comprehensive Plan Amendment.
Should the Planning Commission recommend opposite of staff recommendation,
staff does ask that that the Planning Commission's recommendation considers
adding that the property could only be used for high density residential development,
not commercial development. The property is conducive to high density residential
given its location, the alley access and the other surrounding uses. From a land use
and good planning practices, going to a High Commercial land use is the ideal way
to achieve higher density.
Hans Korve, DMP, Inc. 726 Auburn Wav N, Auburn, WA 98002
Mr. Korve stated that the application meets all the criteria as listed in the
Comprehensive Plan LU-115 and LU-116. Specifically, the proposal explores
innovative mechanisms to encourage more efficient use of land and facilitate the
redevelopment of underutilized land whenever possible. The applicant believes the
proposal is creative and the property is underutilized.
The applicant has hired an architect to design the property based upon
conversations with staff. Mr. Korve reviewed the architectural drawings with the
Commission that were included in the agenda packet. The plan is to develop a
residential-style three story building which compliments an 11-unit, 3-story town
home complex to the south. Mr. Korve noted that the property in question is partially
in a Heavy Commercial and High Density Residential zones. In the current
economy, a 6-unit option does not pencil out for financial lenders; however, a 9-10
option would.
In response to Commission's questions, Mr. Korve said the applicant is not asking for
low-income housing and anticipates middle-income residents. Further, fire
suppression should not be an issue given the appropriate setbacks, alley access and
that the adjoining property has appropriate setbacks. The proposed project will have
a fire sprinkler system.
Chair Roland asked for any further testimony from the audience.
David Green 1604 7"' St NE Auburn WA 98002.
Mr. Green questioned the need for additional Auburn residents without having
sufficient roads. Mr. Green was not in support of this project.
Commissioner Hamilton responded to Mr. Green, stating that the City has to take
additional population as mandated by the Sate Growth Management Act.
Page 6
s
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
There being no one else present to speak regarding the CPM #6, Chair Roland ciosed the
public hearing at 8:11 p.m.
Ms. Chamberlain responded to Commission's question, stating that the alley way
west of the property in question is two-way and is a public right-of-way; it is not part
of the parcel. Further, 24t" Street is a through street from Auburn Way to I Street NE.
The road is full width from Auburn Way to the alley where it then narrows to 20 feet
of pavement to I Street NE. As part of the redevelopment of the property, frontage
improvements to build out half of 24`h Street would be required.
Commission asked staff if there was a middle ground or other options for this
proposed amendment. Staff responded that two options would be to look at the R-20
zone to see if the City needed to change the density or if R-20 is appropriate for a
high density residential zone throughout the city. Staff noted that the Planning
Commission recently reviewed and discussed this zone designation as part of the
Code Update project. Other options would be to review the R20 zone to determine if
it makes sense to have this zone in some locations of the City and not others, add a
R-48 zone as other jurisdictions have, or determine if the City needs more zoning
districts to build in that flexibility.
Staff recommended that a rezone condition be placed on the property that it be
developed only as multifamily. Staff responded to Commission's question stating
that if the property was sold in the future or if the applicant changed the development
design, the applicant would be required to go through the rezone process to remove
that condition.
Chair Roland opened the Public Hearing at 8:17 p.m. to receive further comments.
Mr. Korve stated that the applicant did propose the conditional agreement to staff to
remove any underlying doubt that the property would be developed as proposed.
Additionally, the property is owned by the applicant and financing would be for the
construction, not for property purchase.
There being no one else present to speak regarding the CPM #6, Chair Roland closed the
public hearing at 8:20 p.m.
Commissioner Hamilton moved and Commissioner Copple seconded to recommend
approval of the Craig Commercial Comprehensive Plan amendment, CPM #6 to City
Council, with the provision that the property could only be used for high density
residential development (R-20) and not commercial development (C-3).
MOTION CARRIED 7-1. Commissioner Mason voted no.
D. CPA09-0005 Riverside Villaqe Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Applicant: Ray Keasey
Chair Roland opened the Public Hearing at 8:25 p.m. to receive comments on CMP
#7 Riverside Village Comprehensive Plan Amendment.
Page 7
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
Principal Planner Elizabeth Chamberlain provided an overview of the CPM #7 map
utilizing a PowerPoint presentation; this map was included in the agenda packet.
This comprehensive plan map amendment request is to change the land use
designation of a 1.58 acre (68,825 square feet) parcel located at 1608 8`h Street NE
(Parcel No. 1721059163) from Moderate Density Residential to High Density
Residential. Staff reviewed the current Comprehensive Plan designation, zoning
designation and land uses of the site and surrounding properties.
The subject site is currently developed with 30 single story apartment units that were
constructed in 1968. The property was part of the City when the apartments were
constructed. However, the property was developed prior to the City's 1995 Growth
Management Act Comprehensive Plan (GMA), the City's 1987 original zoning
ordinance and the 1971 Shoreline Management Program (SMP).
Under the existing land use designation of Moderate Density Residential and zoning
of R-10 (Residential 10 du/acre) the number of units already constructed exceeds
the density of the R-10 zone. If the comprehensive plan amendment and
subsequent rezone to R-20 (Residential 20 du/acre) were to be approved by the City
Council, the subject property could potentially yield two additional units.
The property is adjacent to the Green River and within the 200 foot shoreline
management area and any new construction is subject to the City's Shoreline
Management Program. The shoreline designation for this property is Shoreline
Residential. Existing pavement edge is within approximately 60 feet of the Green
River and the property is within the 100 foot buffer. Any future development will be
required to comply with the City's SMP and other development regulations.
Staff supports the proposed land use change to High Density Residential as it brings
the site more in line with how the property is developed.
Rav Keasey, 9800 208th Ave NE, Redmond, WA 98053
Mr. Keasey stated that the proposal is requested for two purposes. Currently, there
are 30 apartment units on the site in a non-conforming use for the current zone.
Because of the non-conforming use, it has been difficult to obtain operational
financing. It was noted that adding additional units are not viable on this property and
the applicant does not have a business case to demolish the existing units and
reconstruct. Secondly, there was a cabana on site which had a fire, it has been
reconstructed and stands vacant. Mr. Keasey considers the proposed
Comprehensive Plan amendment to be administrative, bringing the property into line
with the current zoning.
Robert C. Donihue, 1605 7`h St NE, Auburn, WA
Mr. Donihue reported that he has lived behind the Riverside Village property since
1977. He initially came to the meeting in opposition to the proposed amendment due
to rumors that the current buildings would be torn down and replaced with multistory
apartments. Mr. Donihue now realizes that the proposed amendment is an
administrative request. Mr. Donihue commented that Mr. Keasey has done a much
better job in cleaning up and maintaining the property than previous owners. As long
Page 8
i
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
as there are no new buildings, Mr. Donihue is in support of the proposed
amendments.
There being no one else present to speak regarding the CPM #7, Chair Roland closed the
public hearing at 8:39 p.m.
Commissioner Chapman moved and Commissioner DiTuri seconded to recommend
approval of the Riverside Village Comprehensive Plan Amendment - CPM #7, to City
Council.
MOTION CARRIED 8-0.
Chair Roland recessed the meeting for approximately 5 minutes at 8:40 p.m. for a brief intermission. The meeting was reconvened 8:46 p.m.
A. CPA09-0001 2009 Comprehensive Plan Amendments Group 2
(1) Comprehensive Transportation Plan Amendments P/T #6
Chair Roland opened the Public Hearing at 8:47 p.m. to receive comments
about the Comprehensive Transportation Plan Amendments P/T #6.
Transportation Planner Tiffin Goodman reported that the current Comprehensive
Transportation Plan was updated significantly in 2005. A new planning process
began in 2008 to include the Lea Hill and West Hill annexation areas into the
Plan. The new Plan will also incorporate the updated land use, population, and
employment projects for the planning horizon year 2030 citywide. All chapters
have been updated, with significant changes made to the Street System and
Nonmotorized Transportation chapters. Ms. Goodman reviewed these major
. changes with the Commission.
Projects to address safety and level of service deficiencies anticipated by 2030
are contained in the Street System chapter. They were identified through the
public outreach and modeling processes. Projects proposed are recommended
to be completed within the next 20 years.
Two future project maps are included in the Nonmotorized Transportation
chapter which identify targeted investment projects; Figure 3-2 Future Priority
Sidewalk Corridors and Figure 3-4, Future Bicycle Facilities and Multi-Use Trails.
New recommendations in the Transit chapter include new service in the West Hill
area and an additional route in the Lea Hill area, possibly focusing on
transporting commuters to and from the Transit Station.
There being no one present to speak regarding the 2009 Comprehensive Transportation Plan
Amendments P/T #6, Chair Roland closed the hearing at 8:51 p.m.
Staff will correct Figure 2-2, Average Daily Traffic Volumes, to identify the
average daily traffic volumes on Harvey Rd, between 8th and 15th. Further, staff
Page 9
0
• PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
will correct Figure 4-1, Existing Transit Serving Auburn, to reflect that Metro Bus
Route 154 no longer serves Auburn.
Approximately $25 million was identified as needed to bring current local truck
routes up to the truck route standard. The Citizen's Arteriai Streets Task Force
assisted in prioritizing the truck routes into Priority 1 and Priority 2, which are
shown in Figure 2-3, Truck Route Map. Funding sources for the $25 million are
being sought.
Regarding Figure 3-4, Future Bicycle Facilities and Multi-Used Trails, Ms.
Goodman explained that the blue lines indicate street bike trails. In terms of
having sufficient room on the streets for the bike routes, it would vary by each
street. In corridors where there is not enough right-of-way for a bike route, it
would require a capital project expense or a dedication of property as
development occurs or shared lanes on the road. Ms. Goodman gave details
about the bike lanes on Terrace Drive.
The Plan identifies the priority criteria and areas for sidewalk installation as
shown in Figure 3.2, Future Priority Sidewalk Corridors. The City cannot impose
sidewalk costs to neighborhoods through a Local Improvement District without a
positive vote by the residents, except in cases where enough street delay
agreements have already been signed.
Commissioner Peace moved and Commissioner Hamilton seconded to
recommend approval of the Comprehensive Transportation Plan Amendments
P/T #6 to the City Council.
MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY 8-0
(2) 2009 Storm Drainaqe Comprehensive Plan Update P/T #7
Chair Roland opened the Public Hearing at 9:07p.m. to receive comments
about the 2009 Storm Drainage Comprehensive Plan Update P/T #7
Storm Utility Engineer Tim Carlaw stated the draft Plan under consideration
replaces the current 2002 Plan which was focused on projects and costs. The
2009 Plan is intended to guide the City's Stormwater Drainage utility with respect
to future activities and improvements. Mr. Carlaw reviewed the specific
objectives and changes of the 2009 Stormwater Drainage Plan, which included
developing level of service goals, developing a monitoring plan for data collection
and performing hydraulic modeling analysis. The 2009 Plan additionally contains
a Capital Improvement Plan, storm drainage program administration, water
quality program, and recommended subbasin drainage plans.
Mr. Carlaw responded to Commission's comments and questions as follows.
Staff has modeled a scenario of an overf1ow condition of 17,600 cfs, as provided
by the Army Corps of Engineer, for the Green River should the Howard Hanson
Dam cause flooding. It was noted that this information is not included in the Plan
as it is considered an unusual event. Staff distributed an updated Green River
Page 10
,
PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES OCTOBER 6, 2009
Fiood Impact map that represents areas that could be flooded and sanitary sewer
and stormwater systems could back up in the event of a flood.
There being no one present to speak regarding the 2009 Storm Drainage Comprehensive Plan
Update P/T #7, Chair Roland closed the hearing at 9:18 p.m.
Commissioner DiTuri moved and Commissioner Baggett seconded to
recommend approval of the 2009 Storm Drainage Comprehensive Plan Update
P/T #7 to the City CounciL
MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY 8-0
(3) 2009 Sewer Comprehensive Plan Update P/T #7
Sewer Utility Engineer Robert Elwell reported that the 2009 Plan update replaces
the City's 2001 Comprehensive Sewer Plan. The 2009 Plan examines the
existing sewer service area which includes both areas within the city limits and
Auburn's potential annexation areas. It addresses policies, design criteria, and
recommends improvements to the sewer system and its service area. The Plan
also includes a Capital Improvement Plan for repair and replacement, system
improvements, and extensions of facilities to meet future sewer demands. Mr.
Elwell stated that maintaining a current Plan is required in order to meet
regulations of the Washington Department of Ecology. The Plan is prepared to
serve as a guide for continually maintaining and evaluating the existing sewer
system, and for planning and designing future sewer system facilities. Mr. Elwell
reviewed the specific tasks and objectives of the 2009 Sewer Comprehensive
Plan.
Regarding Figure ES-1, Implementation Schedule, Mr. Elwell answered
Commission's question regarding decommissioning of the Lea Hill Pump Station.
There are two pump stations currently in operation, White Mountain Trails and
Rainier Heights. There is a pump station that is part of a developer project,
which is referred to as the Verdana Pump Station. When this comes online, it will
replace the two pump stations and is designed to handle the flow. Mr. Elwell
stated that the Verdana Pump Station is within the City of Kent; however, it is a
City of Auburn sewer system. There will be some expenditure to re-route flows
from the two pump stations to Verdana.
There being no one present to speak regarding the 2009 Sewer Comprehensive Plan Update
P/T #7, Chair Rofand closed the hearing at 9:34 p.m.
Commissioner Baggett moved and Commissioner Peace seconded to
recommend approval of the 2009 Sewer Comprehensive Plan Update P/T #7 to
the City Council.
MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY 8-0
VI. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Planning Commission, Chair Roland
adjourned the meeting at 9:37 p.m.
Page 11