HomeMy WebLinkAboutITEM V-A-2WASHINGTON
CITY COUNCIL
SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES
NOVEMBER 5, 2009 5:30 PM
I. CALL TO ORDER
Mayor Peter B. Lewis called the special meeting of the City Council to
order at 5:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers of Auburn City Hall located at
25 West Main Street in Auburn for the purpose of discussing the 2009-
2010 Biennial Budget, property tax revenues and other revenue sources.
Mayor Lewis led those in attendance in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Councilmembers present were: Rich Wagner, Sue Singer, Gene Cerino,
Nancy Backus, and Lynn Norman. Councilmember Bill Peloza arrived at
5:32. Councilmember Haugen was excused.
Staff members present included: Information Services Director Lorrie
Rempher; Finance Director Shelley Coleman; Public Works Director
Dennis Dowdy; Police Commander Willard Lathrop; Assistant City
Attorney Steve Gross; Planning, Building and Community Director Cindy
Baker; Chief of Police Jim Kelly; Financial Planning Manager Karen
Jester; Parks, Arts and Recreation Director Daryl Faber; Human
Resources and Risk/Property Management Director Brenda Heineman;
and City Clerk Danielle Daskam.
II. 2010 BUDGET MID TERM ADJUSTMENT
Mayor Lewis noted that the City must set its property tax levy before the
end of the month in order to meet the deadlines established by the
counties. A property tax levy ordinance will be presented to the Council
for consideration on November 16, 2009.
Mayor Lewis reported that he has asked Department Directors to submit
adjusted 2010 budgets that reflect the budget for mandated operations
and budgets that reflect mandated operations as well as other core
services.
Mayor Lewis stated that business district at the north end of Auburn
represents up to sixty percent of the sales tax receipts for the City; and
should a flooding disaster occur in the area, the City's ability to operate
Page 1
Citv of Auburn Council Meetinq Minutes November 5, 2009
would be drastically affected and only mandated operations would be able
to continue.
Using a PowerPoint presentation, Director Coleman reviewed beginning
fund balances from 2008 and 2009 and estimated beginning fund
balances for 2010 and 2011. Finance Director Coleman stated that 2007
was a very good year for revenues and the 2008 beginning fund balance
reflected a healthy beginning fund balance of $14,462,720. In 2009, the
beginning fund balance was $13,071,091. It is estimated that the
beginning fund balance in 2010 will be $9,463,001. Director Coleman
reminded that the Council has mandated an eight percent of expenditures
for reserve; the 2010 projected beginning fund balance does not meet the
eight percent reserve mandate.
BEGINNING FUND BALANCE
Year
Fund
Change
Balance
2008 Beginning FB
$14,462,720
2009 Beginning FB
13,071,091
$
1,391,629
2010 Beginning FB
9,463,001
(3,608,090)
(Estimated)
2011 Beginning FB
$ 2,707,046
$
(Estimated)
(6,755,955)
Note:
➢ Need 8% of expenditures for reserve.
➢ 8% of $53,000,000 is $4,240,000.
➢ 8% of $48,000,000 is $3,840,000.
Page 2
Citv of Auburn Council Meetinq Minutes November 5, 2009
Finance Director Coleman reviewed the 2010 revenue estimates for the
2010 original budget and a proposed revised budget:
2010
Original
Budget
2010
Proposed
Revised
Bud et
Difference
Property Tax
$10,471,900
$ 9,967,000
$ (504,900)
Sales Tax
17,686,100
14,255,000
(3,431,100)
Other Taxes
13,701,700
12,793,600
(908,100)
Licenses & Permits
1,497,500
1,088,000
(409,500)
Intergovernmental
3,816,300
3,746,240
(70,060)
Charges for
Services
2,091,000
2,061,000
(30,000)
Fines & Forfeitures
2,729,700
1,870,700
(859,000)
Miscellaneous
Revenues
486,200
396,200
(90,000)
Other Revenues
42,000
42,000
0
Total Revenues
$52,522,400
$46,219,740
$ (6,302,660)
Director Coleman reviewed the 2010 expenditure estimates for the 2010
original budget and a revised budget:
2010
Original
Budget
2010
Revised
Budget
Difference
Council & Mayor
$807,500
$ 759,200
$(48,300)
Court
17,686,100
14,255,000
(48,700)
Human
Resources
13,701,700
12,793,600
(237,350)
Finance
1,497,500
1,088,000
(89,155)
Legal
3,816,300
3,746,240
(247,285)
Planning
2,091,000
2,061,000
(1,263,400)
Police
2,729,700
1,870,700
(1,314,715)
Engineering
3,980,500
3,341,050
(639,450)
Parks
7,174,400
6,901,950
(272,450)
Streets
486,200
396,200
(48,200)
Page 3
Citv of Auburn Council Meetinq Minutes November 5, 2009
Non
3,980,000
3,980,000
0
De artmental
Total
$57,184,700
$52,975,69
$ (4,209,005)
Ex enditures
5
Director Coleman reviewed a summary of the budget revisions
implemented by 2009 Budget Amendments 1 and 2:
• Froze 12.25 FTE's and departmental cuts
• Froze 24 FTE's from reduction in force
• Removed unaffiliated COLA and VEBA
The net effect of the revisions on the 2010 Budget is approximately $4.2
million.
Director Coleman reviewed revenues currently not levied by the City of
Auburn including a car tab fee. The cities of Des Moines, Edmonds, Lake
Forest Park, Olympia, Prosser and Shoreline have levied a car tab fee.
Director Coleman also presented a comparison of business license fees
for the area. The City of Auburn's current business license fee is a flat
rate of $50 per year. Director Coleman also reviewed business
occupation taxes. The city is limited to a maximum rate of 0.2 percent for
city taxes on business activities that are measured by gross receipts or
gross income. Cities in the area currently imposing business and
occupation taxes on gross receipts or gross income include: Algona,
Bellevue, Burien, Des Moines, Lake Forest Park, Olympia, Pacific and
Tacoma.
Director Coleman reviewed the property tax assessed value:
Page 4
Citv of Auburn Council Meetinq Minutes November 5, 2009
PROPERTY TAX ASSESSED VALUE (AV)
Total 2009 AV
$8,719,721,892
Total 2010 Preliminary AV
$7,819,240,659
Decrease from 2009 AV
-10.33%
New Construction*
2009 Final
$146,832,806
2010 Preliminary
$881243,699
Director Coleman noted that the 2010 preliminary assessed value is
estimated to decrease from 2009 by 10.33%.
Councilmembers discussed the effect of a flooding disaster on the City's
overall assessed valuation.
Director Coleman presented information on property tax banked capacity.
The City has approximately $7 million in banked capacity available;
however, the maximum allowable capacity the City can attain is $3.8
million.
Director Coleman reviewed the 2010 General Fund expenditures (revised
based on 2009 reductions):
2010 Revised
Bud et
Salaries & Benefits
$31,584,195
59.6%
Supplies
1,224,500
2.3%
Other Services & Charges
9,222,800
17.4%
Intergovernmental
4,313,100
8.1 %
Capital Outlay
90,000
0.2%
Debt Service
250,900
0.5%
Fuel & ERR
1,766,700
3.3%
Page 5
City of Auburn Council Meetinq Minutes November 5, 2009
Facilities
1,674,300
3.2%
Information Services
2,849,200
5.4%
Total
$52,975,695
100.0%
In response to a question from Councilmember Peloza, Director Coleman
stated that she believes that the amount of salaries and benefits (sixty
percent) from the General Fund is standard for cities across the state.
Councilmembers briefly discussed the various elements of General Fund
expenditures.
Director Coleman displayed a table illustrating the effect of the property
tax levy on $200,000 and $300,000 homes:
$200,000
Increase
$300,000
Increase
Home
Home
2009 Cit
$298
$447
Lev Actual
010 Ci
335
$ 37
508
$ 61
Levy w/ 101 %
+ NCI
010 Cit
364
29
546
38
Levy w/ NCI
+$1 M
010 Cit
390
26
585
38
Levy w/ NCI
+$2M
010 Cit
415
26
623
38
Levy w/ NCI
+$3M
2010 Cit
436
21
654
31
Levy w/ NCI
+$3.8M
Councilmembers briefly reviewed the table and the effect of reduced
assessed valuation and adding banked capacity.
Director Coleman stated that the proposed property tax levy includes the
transfer of $1.2 million to the Save Our Streets Fund. Director Coleman
clarified that the amount of the transfer is over and above the amount
collected by the SOS levy.
Mayor Lewis pointed out that the General Fund revenue estimate for 2010
is $46.2 million while the 2010 revised budget expenditures currently
Page 6
Citv of Auburn Council Meetinq Minutes November 5. 2009
stand at $52.9 million, a difference of approximately $6 million. Mayor
Lewis stated that the downturn in the economy has resulted in the City's
revenue base being reset at the 2010 levels. Mayor Lewis anticipates that
the economy will recover at a rate of two percent per year at best.
Mayor Lewis reported that budget talks continue with all departments as
well as with the unions. Mayor Lewis stated that a revised 2010 Budget
will be prepared by the end of November.
Deputy Mayor Singer noted that in order to reduce expenditures by $5
million, the City will need to reduce services. Mayor Lewis responded that
the City intends to provide the best service possible with the workforce
that remains.
Councilmember Cerino suggested providing the Council with estimates of
the amount of revenue that could be generated from other sources.
Councilmember Peloza stated that if the City is successful in reducing its
expenses through negotiation with staff and the unions, the level of
service should remain the same; however, if the negotiations are not
favorable, then reduction in services must be considered in order to
balance the budget.
Councilmembers briefly discussed the components of property tax, i.e.
property tax levied by county, state, port, library, Valley Regional Fire
Authority, schools and other special districts.
Councilmember Wagner questioned the amount of reductions made by
the Auburn Municipal Court to date. Finance Director Coleman stated that
in 2008 three positions in the Court were frozen and removed from the
2009 and 2010 budgets.
Finance Director Coleman advised that if the unions agree to concede
their 2010 VEBA contributions and COLA's, the savings would be
approximately $850,000.
At 6:40 p.m., Mayor Lewis recessed the meeting to executive session for
approximately twenty minutes in order to discuss pending/potential
litigation pursuant to RCW 42.30.110(1)(i). Staff members attending the
executive session included Assistant City Attorney Steve Gross, Human
Resources and Risk/Property Management Director Heineman and
Finance Director Shelley Coleman.
At 7:00 p.m., Mayor Lewis reconvened the regular meeting.
Page 7
Citv of Auburn Council Meetinq Minutes November 5, 2009
III. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Council, the meeting
adjourned at 7:00 p.m.
APPROVED THE DAY OF NOVEMBER 2009.
Peter B. Lewis, Mayor Danielle Daskam, City Clerk
City Council agendas and minutes are available to the public at the City Clerk's
Office, on the City website, and via e-mail. Complete agenda packets are
available for review at the City Clerk's Office and at the Library.
Internet: http://www.auburnwa.gov
Page 8