HomeMy WebLinkAboutITEM III-AC ~ DRAFT
PLANNING & COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
* ~HIG~"OI
June 22, 2010
MINUTES
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Lynn Norman called the meeting to order at 5:00 p.m. in Annex Conference Room
1 located on the second floor of One Main Building, 1 East Main Street, Auburn, WA.
Committee members present were: Chair Lynn Norman, Vice Chair Nancy Backus and Member Rich Wagner.
Councilmember Partridge was also in attendance as an audience member.
Staff members present included: Mayor Pete Lewis, Deputy Mayor Singer, Planning
Director Kevin Snyder, City Attorney Heid, Finance Director Coleman, Information
Services Director Rempher, Public Works Director Dowdy, Planning Manager
Chamberlain, Building Official Hopkins, Risk Manager Roscoe, Environmental Manager
Anderson, and Administrative Support Clerk Kriss.
II. ACTION
There were no Action Items forthis agenda.
III. DISCUSSION and INFORMATION
A. EnvironmentallEconomic Development Initiatives and Planning Deputy Mayor Singer presented on ACCENT -Auburn Scientific Center for Emergent
New Technologies.
Deputy Mayor Singer explained she and Councilmember Wagner have been working
on populating the Green Zone with environmentally friendly business, this being a
City Vision 2016 goal. The original concept provided for:
1. Producing green collar jobs in the Puget Sound Region;
2. Connecting research universities to the private sector;
3. Providing incubation services to assist them to the commercialization by
connecting them with Green River Community College
Mayor Lewis asked if WSU's project was a sub program of ASCENT. Deputy Mayor
Singer stated it is one of the members of the group - a project is a member of the
group. Deputy Mayor Singer explained ACTIA, Alliance for Clean Technology
Incubators and Accelerators is intended to provide regional support.
Planning and Community Development Committee Minutes June 22, 2010
Mayor Lewis stated the 16 Challenge Grant is something that helps ACENT Phase 1,
ACTIA and the Auburn Innovation Center Phase 2.
Deputy Mayor Singer presented and discussed the five concurrent projects that are
part of ASCENT:
1. WSU Sustainability Project;
2. ASCENT Incubator, Phase 1;
3. ACTIA Partnership;
4. $1M 16 Challenge Grant;
5. Auburn Innovation Center with Phase 2 of ASCENT
Deputy Mayor Singer turned the report over to Councilmember Wagnerto present
the WSU Sustainability Projects.
Councilmember Wagner directed the attention of the committee to page 6, of the
Project ASCENT Incubator handout and discussed the Washington State University
Sustainability Projects.
Councilmember Wagner referred to the map on page 6 pointing out Phase 1 and 2 in
green and highlighting the blue Environmental Park District, Clean Tech Development Area. A proposed Transit-Oriented Multi-Family & Mixed-Use
Commercial Area is highlighted in yellow.
Deputy Mayor Singer directed the Committee's attention to page discussing the
status and needs of Incubator ASCENT Phase 1.
Members asked the size of the former Information Services building. Deputy Mayor
Singer answered stating she believes it is approximately 1,100 square feet and only
the current members of ASCENT would be housed in the building. All other virtual
clients will not be tenants of the building but be served offsite.
Members asked if the City would have liabilities with the virtual clients or connections
it would coordinate. Deputy Mayor Singer did not feel there would be any legal
liabilities due to legal agreements that would be executed between the City and
anyone interested in incubation.
Member Backus asked if the CBDG funds would be repaid and if we would receive
more CBDG funds than the City received in the past from this fund. Deputy Mayor
Singer replied the CBDG grant would be a separate economic development fund
from years past with no match or loan, she stated she has been informed the City is
eligible forthese funds.
Deputy Mayor Singer explained it would cost less than $25,000 for Phase 1. Mayor
Lewis explained the nanotech scientists will get 1M - $3M in federal grant starter
money but need to take their product to the commercial level, and this would bean
opportunity to seed an industry with a modest start.
Deputy Mayor Singer directed attention to page 8 of the presentation, and
specifically "What Clients Get" and discussed the networking services they would
receive.
Page 2
Planning and Community Development Committee Minutes June 22, 2010
Members asked who would be liable from any legal advice provided by ACTIA.
Deputy Mayor Singer replied that ACTIA will have one of the largest patent attorneys
in the region working with it that is willing to provide $20,000. in legal services up
front to clients of ASCENT. She stated that an agreement would be signed by the
attorneys and clients so the City would not be liable.
Deputy Mayor Singer noted that because the patent attorneys would be part of the
ACTIA network providers they would provide their service up front and expect to get
paid in the next layer of funding.
Deputy Mayor Singer directed the Committee's attention to page 9 of the presentation, and briefed Committee on "What Auburn Gets" in return for office
space and services.
Member Backus asked if ASCENT members would be required to sign an agreement
keeping their business and manufacturing in the City of Auburn. Attorney Heid
responded and suggested language that promotes or encourages members to do so
could be placed in the agreements.
Deputy Mayor Singer referred to page 12 of the presentation, showing a list of
parties who have committed their support or desire to partnership with ACTIA and gave brief information about each party and discussed the specifics of ACTIA.
Deputy Mayor Singer next discussed the I-6 Challenge Grant and explained to the
Committee the money would go directly to the Small Business Assistance Center
and the funding would be $37,500.00 with the additional $50,000.00. SBAC would
be the project manager to get the Auburn Innovation Center built.
Mayor Lewis suggested putting the Small Business Assistance Center grant funds in
the City budget and hire a contract individual from the grant to do the work. Mayor
Lewis stated the first task is performing the work Small Business Assistance Center
already provides and the second task s having an individual carry us through Phase 2.
Committee asked if there would be alteration costs for ventilation or tenant
improvements at the IS building. Mayor Lewis answered stating if the building is
altered by putting in fans, hoods or other items the cost of improvement would be
shared by the ASCENT partnership but the improvements would stay with the City
upon vacancy. ASCENT partnership would pay for alternations and/or all lab
equipment, tabletops or other fixtures but would retain those items upon vacancy.
Mayor Lewis explained this is a planning grant to position the City to plan to go forward and Mayor Deputy Singer would need the consensus of Council that it would
be ok for the City to move forward with the grant. Council still has the ability to make
a decision if any City funds are contemplated to be used.
Members asked if the grant money could be used, planning occur over several years
and than the City decides to not to move forward. Mayor Lewis responded yes.
Page 3
Planning and Community Development Committee Minutes June 22, 2010
Committee asked if the City needed the IS building what would happen to the tenant. Deputy Mayor Singer stated the tenant would move and if another City facility was
available the City could provide it. Mayor Lewis concurred.
Mayor Lewis clarified that the idea is to go forward if Council is supportive of Phase
1, allowing ASCENT to use the former Information Services space in the Chamber
building and apply forthe grant. If the grant is awarded ASCENT moves to the
planning process for the next two years anticipating the use of the City land in the
Environmental Park to build a facility without cost to the City, as long as Council is
supportive.
Mayor Lewis asked City Attorney Heid can the Committee give consensus. Mr. Heid
stated the Committee can indicate individually how they are willing to proceed.
Chair Norman requested items go through City Attorney Heid and Risk Manager
Roscoe.
Committee members asked what other staff support and oversight would be needed
and would it be a full-time employee?
Mayor Lewis clarified that the following was needed:
1. Consensus to move forward with Phase 1, the i6 Challenge Grant; and,
2. Consensus that moving forward with ASCENT as a program of the City.
Mayor Lewis added administration would decide on the programs and staffing;
PCDC first, and then Council would need to give consensus forthe Mayorto setup a
program called ASCENT and work on appropriate staff support. Next, City Attorney
Heid would draft appropriate legal agreements for the City to join ACTIA.
City Attorney Heid explained either Mayor Lewis could recommend to City Council Deputy Mayor Singer's appointment to the Board of Directors of ACTIA or City
Council would recommend the appointment depending on how it is set up.
Committee members asked Deputy Mayor Singer if she is already on the board.
Deputy Mayor replied yes. Mayor Lewis explained to the Committee that Deputy
Mayor Singer would be acting as a private citizen on the board but is waiting on
appointment.
Chair Norman asked City Attorney Heid if he can work on a resolution that will work
for both parties. Attorney Heid answered yes and he will meet with Deputy Mayor Singer.
Member Wagner stated he would strongly support if the 16 Challenge Grant but only
if the Committee is not making a commitment for $100,000 - $150,000 per year.
Member Wagner stated he would like to address any financial commitment on behalf
of the City at a later time.
Member Backus stated she is supportive of going forward with the grant only, but
based on the information provided tonight is not supportive of any financial
Page 4
Planning and Community Development Committee Minutes June 22, 2010
commitment on the part of the City; she stated she is open to this being brought before Committee at a latertime.
Member Wagner stated he is supportive of the potential use of City land in the
Environmental Park for a future facility on a personal level but would like to have this
brought before the Committee again at the end of the planning period to make the
land available.
Deputy Mayor Singer asked Member Wagner at what level of planning he would
want to continue on this project. Member Wagner replied he is supportive going
forward to apply with the 16 Challenge Grant and providing $50,000 per year if we get the 16 Grant.
Members stated they would be willing to move forward with the grant application and
if awarded, the City will, within two years, have more information and an idea of what
this means to the City; the Committee anticipates that the City would be pursuing
additional grant funding for this project also.
Chair Norman asked if there are other comments and members stated there is a lot
of information to digest to make a decision or commitment at this time.
Mayor Lewis asked if the Committee had reached consensus on whether it would
support the Mayor requesting Council approval to appoint Deputy Mayor Singerto
the ACTIA board and also for Council support forthe Mayor to establish ASCENT as
a City program and authorize the use of the former Information Services work space
as work space for the group of clean tech scientists previously discussed.
Committee members asked if Deputy Mayor Singerwould be a member on the
ACTIA board on behalf of the City if the City is only partnering with ACTIA. Mayor
Lewis answered the City will not be a member of ACTIA until ACTIA has a status
which allows us to do so. Deputy Mayor Singerwould be appointed as a private
citizen, and ACTIA could be a potential funding mechanism forAuburn's program.
City Attorney Heid advised the Mayor that he can act within his authority, on a
commitment that would not exceed $25,000. Mayor Lewis concurred stating it is
within his authority to expend $25,000 as long as he does not exceed this amount.
City Attorney Heid added Mayor Lewis could designate Deputy Mayor Singer as a
liaison from the City to work with on this partnership and serve in a capacity
compatible as directed by the separate nonprofit.
Mayor Lewis asked if there was Committee consensus on an individual commitment by Deputy Mayor Singerto act a liaison from the City to ACTIA. Members all stated
yes as long as it meets our legal criteria.
Mayor Lewis added it is worthwhile to move forward to use the former Information
Services space for the visiting scientists from WSU and the nanotech scientists as
long as they commit to financially providing for any improvements. Mayor Lewis
asked if Committee would commit to this. Committee Members stated yes.
Page 5
Planning and Community Development Committee Minutes June 22, 2010
Member Backus stated as long as there is an understanding improvements made to
the building will stay with the City if they vacate the building and they will not profit
from those.
Mayor Lewis stated he does not mind continuing working on the i6 Challenge Grant.
The i6 Challenge grant is a planning grant and as long as the grant does not require
the City to put up a building within the two years, he asked if the Committee would
commit to continue working on the grant.
Member Backus said she does not have a problem with a planning grant but could
not commit at this present time any City funds if the grant is not awarded to this project.
Mayor Lewis clarified the commitment is forthe use of the rectangular piece of land
only and underthe condition the grant is awarded forthe project.
Member Backus stated she is ok with the use of the land, not ownership.
Mayor Lewis shared his appreciation for the consensus and stated the Committee
can bring this back if the grant is not awarded to the project and see if the Committee
is interested in putting forth the $100,000 - $150,000 per year at a later time.
Chair Norman restated she is not prepared to answer this tonight because
Committee can't make a financial decision until you know you have the money.
Member Backus stated they have nothing from Finance telling us if this is feasible or
what the funding source is and could not commit without that information.
Mayor Lewis stated they were asked, separate from the other 3 things, if they would
or would not commit to providing funds if the grant was not awarded to the project.
Member Wagner stated he would be willing to consent to $50,000 but not $150,000
Member Backus stated she is not saying this isn't a great idea but feels she would
still like to make a commitment with more solid financial information and a business a
business plan or financial plan.
Member Backus feels enough information was provided to give consensus for the
other three items but wanted to go on record stating she didn't feel she had enough
information to go forward with the financial portion and was concerned about the
limited time to make the decision.
Mayor Lewis asked staff if they felt there was enough consensus with the Committee
members, directors and staff to carry out the use of the IS building, applying for the
grant and going to Council forthe appointment and planning.
City Attorney Heid stated yes he believes he can put together an agreement to
accomplish his responsibility for legal documentation to support the City joining
ACTIA.
Page 6
Planning and Community Development Committee Minutes June 22, 2010
Mayor Lewis asked if there is enough information to go forward to accomplish what
needs to be done without the financial commitment for additional funds.
Members clarified as to whetherthey were being asked if they were just giving their
opinion tonight. City Attorney Heid stated the Committee is not making a decision for
the City Council. Mayor Lewis stated he felt Committee would be interested in
bringing back the financial portion for discussion at a latertime, but this would need
to include additional detailed information and clarification.
Mayor Lewis explained he felt any commitment for funds in the amount of
$100,000 - $150,000 as an alternative to the grant would be a discussion item at the retreat in the fall.
Chair Norman emphasized her concern that major decisions were made from
information provided for discussion and if the intent was all or nothing that would be
a step too far for her.
IV. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Planning and Community
Development Committee, Chair Norman adjourned the meeting at _6:54 p.m.
APPROVED THIS DAY OF
Lynn Norman, Chair Tina Kriss, Administrative Support Clerk
Page 7