Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout11-21-2011 * . *' Public Works Committee cinoc,-�� ; November 21, 2011 - 3:30 PM Annex Room 2 'WASHINGTON MINUTES J. CALL TO ORDER Chairman Rich Wagner called the meeting to order at 3:30 p.m. in Conference Room #2, located on the second floor of Auburn City Hall, One East Main Street, Auburn, Washington. A. Roll Call Chairman Wagner and Vice-Chair BiII Peloza were pres.ent. Also present during the meeting were: Mayor Pete B. Lewis, Public Works Director Dennis Dowdy, City EngineedAssistantDirec#or Dennis Selle, Assistant City Engineer Ingrid_Gaub, Traffic Engineer Pablo Para, Engineering Aide _ Amber Mund, Project Engineer Robert Lee, Street Systems Engineer Seth Wickstrom, Project Engineer Ryan Vondrak, Project Engineer Jacob Sweeting, Storm Drainage Engineer Tim Ca.rlaw, Water Utility Engineer Cynthia Lamothe, Sanitary Sewer Engineer Robert Elwell, Planning Director Kevin Snyder, Principal Planner Jeff Dixon, and Public Works Secretary Jennifer Rigsby. Members of the public in attendance included: Councilmember-Elect Wayne Osborne and Councilmember-Elect John Holman. Member Haugen was absent. B. Announcements C. Agenda Modifications There were three agenda modifications, Consent ltem H, Resolution A, and Discussion Item F: II. CONSENT AGENDA A. Approval of Minutes (Dowiiy) � Councilmember Peloza moved and Councilmember Wagner seconded to Approve the Public Works Committee Meeting minutes for date, November 7, 2011. Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . B. Right-of-Way Use Permit No. 11-31 (Mund) Page 1 of 13 Councilmember Peloza moved and Councilmember Wagner seconded to Approve Right-of-Way'Use Permit No. 11-31 for Auburn AdVentist-Academy. Engineering Aide Mun,d.explained that the Auburn Adventist Academy has applied for a Right-of-Way Use PermiYfor April 29, 2012 to hold a half- marathon fund raiser fortheir school. Mund reviewed the running route with the Committee. The Academy is responsible for providing their own traffic control and is respons'ible for having off-duty police officers or cer[ified flaggers control the irrtersections. Chairman Wagner asked how the neigh6orhood wili be notified by the applicant, as stated in Special Condition No. 6. Engineering Aide Mund answered that the applicant will be doing individual mailings. Engineering Aide Mund stated that the applicant is responsible for paying for off-duty pol.ice or fiaggers to control the intersections during their event, _ in response toa questiorrasked by Vice-Chair Peloza. Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . C. Public Works Project No. CP0921 (Lee) Councilmember Peloza moved and Councilmember Wagner seconded to grant permission to initiate Project No. CP0921 Bi- Annual Sanitary Sewer Repair & Replacement. Project Engineer Lee stated that this is a Bi-annual program and the projecYsscope of work includes replacing damaged mains or performing intemal spot repairs. Lee answered questions asked by Chairman Wagner regarding the main replacement on E Main Street and R Street SE. Chairman Wagnerasked aboutthe traffic control planfior Auburn Way S during the time that work is being done.; Project Engineer Lee re.sponded that the main is located outside of the driVing path and it is an internal repair so work will no# affect traffic. Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . D. Public WorksAnnual On=Call Professional Services (Gaub) Councilmember Peloza moved and Councilmember Wagner seconded to �ecommend that the City Council approve the Annual On-Call Professional SerVice Agreements and Amendments for 2012. Assistant City Engineer Gaub explained tFiat the consultants are all on call Page 2 of 13, so if staff needs their expertise they can be use, whether it is for specific projector for assistance during ihe development process. Assistant City Engineer Gaub explained that the on-call agreements are primarily used to supplement staff when doing internal design or engineering work that has not been formally contracted to a consultant to do, in r"esponse to a question asked by Chairman Wagnec Gaub stated that the agreements also include modeling work for the water, sanitary sewer, storm, and transportation systems. Assistant City Engineer Gaub described how work is assigned to and completed by the on-call consultants using task orders, in response to a question asked by Vice-Chair Peloza. Motion Carried Unanimously.2-0. Those absent: Haugen . E. Public Works Project No. CP1121 (Wickstrom) Councilmember Peloza moved and Councilmember Wagner s.econded to recommend that the Gity Council,grant perm.ission to advertise for Rroject IVo. CP1121 —2011 Local Street Pavement Reconstruction — Phase 2 Street Systems Engineer Wickstrom confirmed for the Committee that Phase 2 included all of the rebuild streets. Street Systems Engineer Wickstrom stated that there is a storm drainage problem north of 2nd Street on Pike Street and that is why the intersection is being replaced to both north and soutfi of 3he intersection, in response to a question asked'by Chairman Wagner. Street Systems Engineer Wickstrom stated that there will be new curbing along H Street SE, in response to a question asked by Vice-Chair Peloza. Vice-Chair Peloza asked for the cost of the repairs to just H Street. Street Systems Engineer Wickstrom stated the cost is approximately $250,000.00 for just the street repairs. Wickstrom stated that residents will be notified of fhe work being scheduled for their streets early in 2012. Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . F. Public Works Project No. CP1005 (Vondrak) Councilmember Peloza moved and Councilmember Wagner seconded to recommend that the City Council approve Change Order No. 3 in the Amount of $102,250.00 to ContractNo. 11-08 on Project No. CP1005 South Division Street Promenade. Page 3 of 13 Chairman Wagner asked if there is any way to trace back the original owner of #he abandoned underground storage tank. Project Engineer Vondrak stated that staff has done some research and has sent out letters to the current and former property owners regarding potential liability. Project Engineer Vondrak stated that:the change order amount has not affected the budget for improvements to the plaza, in response to a question asked by Chairman Wagner. Vice-Chair Peloza asked how much liquid had to be pumped out of the abandoned tanks. Project Engineer Vondrak answered that there were no chemicals in the tank and it had been filled with sand. Assistant Director/City Engineer Selle stated that everything will be ADA accessible once the project is complete, in response to a question asked by Vice-Chair Peloza. Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . G. Public Works Project No. CP0756 (Sweeting) Councilmember Peloza moved and Councilmember Wagner seconded to �ecommend that the City Council approve Final Pay Estimate No. 4 to Contract:No. 11-02.in the Amount of$78,549.44 for a Total Contract Price of $486,927.14 with Hoffman Construction, Inc. and AccepYConstruction of Project No. CP0756 Lea Hill Pump Station Decommissioning Phase 2. Motion Carried Unanimousty. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . H. Public Works Project No. C201 A (Sweeting) CouncilmemberPeloza:moved and Councilmember Wagner seconded fo recommend that fhe City Council grant permission to advertise for bids for Project No. C201 A; M Street Underpass Project. Chairman Wagner congratulated staff on the award of the Transportation Improvement Board grant. Assistant Director/City Engineer Selle explained the process of obligating funds to projects during darious stages of p�oject development, in response to a question asked 6y Chairman Wagner. Chairman Wagner asked if ail of the funds for the project are obligated. Project Eng'ineer Sweeting confirmed that all of the funds will be obligated prior to the project being advertised for bid. Page 4 of 13 Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . I II. ORDINANCES A. Ordinance No. 6391 (Carlaw) An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Aubum, Washington, Amending Chapter 13.41 of the Aubum Ciry Code Relating to Utility Systems Development Charge Councilmember Peloza moved and Counciimember Wagner seconded to recommend that the Ciry Council introduce and adopt Ordinance No. 6391. Assistant DirectodCity Engineer Selle explained that developers still have to meet#he adopted design requirements no matter what type of Low Impact Development methods they use, in order to haye.their plans and permits approved, in response to a question asked by Chairman Wagner. Chairman Wagner asked about the appeai procedure outlined in Section 13.41.070. Mayor Lewis pointed out thatthe appeals process in section 13.41.070 applied to collection of fees. The Committee and staff discussed bond indebtedness. Vice-Chair Peloza asked for the definition of "service unit." Storm Drainage Engineer Carlaw answered that the service unit for the Storm Utiliry has been determined to be 2,600 sq ft of impervious surface. Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . IV. RESOLUTIONS A. Resolution No. 4776 (Sweeting) A Resolution of the City Council of the Ciry of Auburn, Washington, , Authorizing the Mayor to Accept a Grant from the Washington State Transportation Imp�ovement Board for Construction of the M Stree4 SE Underpass Project Councilmember Peloza moved and Gounciimember _ _ ____ Wagner seconded to recommend that the City Council adopt Resolution No. 4776. Motion Carried Unanimously. 2-0. Those absent: Haugen . V. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. 2011 Comprehensive Plan Amendments (Dixon) Referencing page 60 of 82 of the age�da packet, Chairman Wagnerasked why the word "industrial"was added to the description and purpose of fhe _ Page 5 of 13 Stuck River Road and Mount Rainier Vista Special Plan areas, P/T#71. Principal Planner Dixon explained that the recommended amendment is in relationship to a privately initiated Comprehensive Plan amendment application thaf the City received fhis year to embark on the process of preparation of a special area plan for the Stuck River Road and Mount Rainier Vista Special Plan areas. Dizon statedthat these initial text amendments will:set 4he'stage for future plan preparation and identifies the future land uses to be studied within the special plan areas. Chairman Wagner pointed out that the word "industrial" in not included on page 14-21 of the Comprehensive Plan. Principal Planner Dixon stated that the word was added at the Planning Commission Hearing at the request of both the applicant and the City. The Mayor and Chairman Wagner discussed the reason as to why the applicant and the City requested that "industrial" be inciuded. Principal Planner Dixon stated that the applicanYs testimony at the hearing was that they were supportive of inclusion of industrial land uses and planning commission agreed with the �ecommendation for the potential range of uses 3hat could be considered for study in that future special area plan effort. Dixon pointed out that when the special area plan is finally prepared to be incorporated into the City?s Comprehensive Plan, it would require an additional Planning Commission Hearing and City Council action to add it in the future. Dixon responded that the Comprehensive Plan notebooks will be updated prior to future action 6y the Committees and Council, adding "industrial"to page 14-21 , following a question asked by Chairman Wagner. Principal Planner Dixon said that the purpose of this proposed text amendment is to allow for the potential uses for the area.to be evaluated and studied. The proposal do.es not change the colored map designation, in response to a comment made tiy Chairman Wagner against industrial uses being allowed in such a large area. Chairman Wagner stated that the text recommendation now opens up an additional 300 acres:to be considered f.or industrial use and spoke against that. Principal Planner Dixon responded that the evaluation of industrial land uses could resultin a more narrow scope on the type of industrial uses that are allowed in the special plan area. Dixon used the Lakeland Hills South area as an example of a large master planned area subject to a special area plan. The Committee and staff continued discussion the recommended text amendment_Chairman Wagner spoke against opening up.an additional 300 Page 6 of 13 acres to industrial development. As an example of how the future development could be phased, Principal Planner Dixon described the reclamation process that has already been started in the area. Chairman Wagner spoke about reconsidering the amendment to limit the industrial uses only to the areas with existing industrial use; the mining areas. Dixon pointed out the part of the amendment is gea,red toward determining what the extent, location and type of industrial might be appropriate.. The Committee and staff discussed the history of the special plan area and that the purpose is to establish the appropriate type and manner of development. Principal Planner Dixon explained that the purpose of the discussion is to share with the Committee the progress of the Planning Gommission's recommendations on the Comprehensive Plan map and text amendments and the Council can choose to go with the Commission's recommendations or not. The recommendations are not going to Council for action until December 5, 2011. Mayor Lewis asked that Chairman VUagner's recommendations to limit the potential industrial uses be taken to the Pianning and Community Development Committee at their 11-28-11 Meeting. Chairman Wagner noted a difference between the text changes emphasizing manufac#uring uses and the summary of the same issue provided in staff memo related to P/T#10: Planning Director Snyder stated that the difference is attr'ibutable to Planning Commission recommendation that staff looks at the potential to use incentives to encourage and facilitate transition of areas in the City away from warehouses and distribution uses. In relation to P!f#5 and the Gity's Capital Facilities Plan, Chairman Wagner spoke about the importance of investing in community building amongst diverse cultures through,the development of public facility buildings. Chairman Wagner asked staff to include an additional goal in Chapter 2 that states the City will try to enhance the community and enhance the inclusion of new residents. Mayor Lewis agreed. Also in relation to P/T #5 and the City's Capital Facilities Plan page 17 Planning DirectorSnyder and Principal Planner Dixon addressed the concerns of Chairman Wagner regarding GMA regulations and the City's effort to improve the Level of Service (LOSj.along corridors and at intersections. ChairWagnerwanted to ensure thatJanguage reflects use of iMersection and corridor LOS which it does. Page 7 of 13 Also in relation to P/T#5 Chairman Wagner suggested including the Engineering funds for projecis #6 (S 277th St—Aubum Way North to Green River Bridge) and #8 (A St NW phase 2) in order to complete some preliminary engineering and begin applying for grants, referencing page 22 of the Capital Facilities Plan. Chair VNagner also commented that Project #4 (I St NE) will be influenced by the development agreement. Chairman Wagner verified with Planning Director Snyder that there were no changes made to the Bicycle Task Force language amending the Transportation Plan P/T#6. Chairman Wagner asked if the Climate Protection and Air Quality section is _ _ _ in response to the carbon footprint study. Principal Planner Dixon answered that the section is an effort to build on the inver�tory that the City has already completed and puts some policy guidance in place P!T#9. Vice-Chair Peloza spoke in favor of P/T# 9 which supports the enyironment and energy efficiency and that it mirrors the Nation League of Cities policies. Vice-ChairFeloza.asked if staff reviews the National League of Cities policies. Planning Director Snyder stated that Environmental Planner Anderson reviewed a suite of different policy statements by different organizations,'in which the National League of Cities is included. B. Resolution No. 4765 (Snyder) A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Auburn, Washington authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to execute a Memorandum of Agreement with Ceradimm, LLC replacing and superseding the Master Development Agreemenf with Alpert International, LLLP previously approved by passage of Resolution No. 4663 Planning Director Snyder explained that the language in the agreement has been updated. The new language is represented in Section 3. The Planning and Gommunity Development Committee did recommend adoption of the revised Resolution No: 4765. Snyder explained the revisions to the language in Section 3. Planning Director Snyder answered that a 30 day time frame is an industry standard for the amount of time provided for communication between finro parties during a land transaction, in response to a question asked by Vice- Chair Peloza regarding the last paragraph of page 69 or 82. C. Traffic Signal Timing (Para) Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter presenied information regarding the traffic signals in the City and the basics of signal timing to the Committee. Nutter stated that there are 91 operating traffic signals in the City and 66 Page 8 of 13 are remotely accessible from the central signal control system, ITS. Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter explained that traffic signal coordination plans are strongly influenced by dynamic conditions such as, corridor speeds, traffic signal spacing, congestion, traffic volumes, pedestrian volumes, traffic signal cycle lengths, signai phasing and intersection geometry. Using a diagram of a generic intersection, Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter demonstrated a typical 8 phase signaf operation for the Committee. Nutter rev'iewed signal timing and cycle lengths. Staff uses modeling software to set signal timing and the timing is based on the required traffic movements at an intersection and their traffic volumes. Assistant Direcfor/City Engineer Selle clarified that software is used for modeling to seTthe basic timing plan and then the timings are programmed into the computer that runs the signal, in response to a question asked by Vice-Chair Peloza. Chairman Wagner asked how long the City has been using the software, Synchro. Traffic Operations Engineers answered fhat the City has been using Synchro for over 15 years, since the software was first released. Selle explained that Synchro is a very common software used industry wide and that staff continues to monitor the industryto see if better software has been developed, in response to a question asked by Vice-Chair Peloza. Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter explained howsignal timing is calculated and coordinated between intersections taking into account multiple intersections in a corridor, intersection geometry, different pedestrian crossings, etc. Assisfant Director/City Engineer Selle explained that when staff is reviewing timing for individual intersections, they are not giving preference to North/South or EasUVUest directional traffic, staff is trying to make the intersection function efficierrtly taking into consideration all of the traffic volumes, in response to a question asked by Vice-Chair Peloza regarding the timing along the Auburn Way corridor. Chairman Wagner commented that ifthe signal timing is calculated using just traffic volume and not queue length then there is preference being giving to the commuter routes because those routes have the highest volume counts. Chairman 1Nagner asked if the Synchro software will take into consideration queue lengths at intersections. Traffic Operations Engineers Nutter said that tfie software:wilf show queue lengths when modeling several intersections in multiple infersections. Selle stated that if signals are not timed based on traffic volumes then it can negatively affect access to adjacent properties as queue lengths on higher volume streets will be longer in length and in duration. Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter discussed the factors that impacts signal timing, such as, that not every signal has Video detection and pedestrian Page 9 of 13 volumes. Nutter reviewed the different scenarios caused by pedestrian crossings and volumes. Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter spoke about how emergency vehicle preemptions affect signal timing. Nutter stated that when the signal timing is interrupted by emergency vehicles it can take up to 15 minutes to readjust and get back into progression. CFiairman Wagner asked from how far away are the emergency vehicles detected bythe signals. Nutter answered the distance is approximately 2 blocks and the vehicles can potentially trigger 3 or 4 signals at a tirrie. Other factors that impact signal coordination include congestion and queuing on major streets and timing changes that may be made to other signals along the same corridor. Assistant Direc[or/City Engineer Selle discussed the far reaching implications to the entire signal system when seemingly minor timing changes are made to one signal movement. Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter reported that the Manual for Uniform Traffic Control DeVices has increased the amount of time required to allow for pedestrian crossings which will in turn impact signal timing. The Committee and staff discussed howpermissive and protected lefts affect signal timing. Chairman Wagner asked how staff decided whether or not left turns should 6e protected. Traffic Engineer Para answered that it is a balance of safety and include such factors as the volume of left tums versus the volume of through traffic and collision history are considered when making a decision. Chairman Wagnerasked if there is anything besides emergency vehicles that can cause a signal synchronization change. Traffic Engineer Para answered that detection failures and loop failures can also impact signal timing management. Staff discussed how the weather and vehicle color can affect detection by the older cameras. Assistant Director/City Engineer Selle discussed how complaints regarding signal time are investigated and followed up on by staff, in response to a question asked by Chairman Wagner. Chairman Wagner asked if the detection cameras can evaluate queues at intersections. Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter explained that the detection cameras are set similar to the loops, in multiple detection zones. Chairman Wagner asked how many of the intersections were equipped with older detection cameras and how many had rriore current detection cameras. Traffic Operations Engineer Nutter answered that there are about 10 intersections that need updated cameras. Nutter stated that staff is _ working on.replacing the cameras on the 15thStreet NW/Auburn Way N . Page 10 of 13 and 8th Street NE/Auburn Way N intersections. Chairman Wagner asked for staff to present the Committee with addiUonal information on how signal timing coordinates with Level of Service (LOS) goals. Assistant Director/City Engineer Selle stated that staff will present more material on LOS in January 2012. D. Striping and Pavement Marking Contract (Para) Traffic Engineer Para summarized the contracting procedure used forthe Citywide Striping and Payement Marking contracts. Para stated that the City has been using King County for the striping project since 2008 and in 2011 the City also used Pierce County to complete work south of the White Rivec. Both agencies did a very good job and there were no complaints about the work. Traffic Engineer Para reported that, based on preliminary calculations, King County provided a better value to the City. Traffic Engineer Para stated that King County is equipped with high-end paint trucks that proyide extremely high productivity and value to the City. Para also said that the County has 6een responsive to customer complaints and has been extremely responsive and flexible to City requests. Director powdy pointed out that the City has not had to answer to any claims. Chairman Wagner asked what the concernswere when private contractors did the striping. Traffic Engineer Para answered that fhere were some issueswith the Contractor's quality control, noYgetting enough beads in the paint, not controlling the traffic to prevenYcars from tracking paint, and lack of flexibility. Director powdy added that fhe painf used by the private contractor was of a lower quality and was more easily tracked along the roadway by vehicles. Assistant Director/City Engineer Selle commented that contracting with King County also saves staff time and man hours because staff does not have to prepare the project forthe formal bid process; administer the contract, provide irispection, issue oFiange orders; and manage the construction. Selle pointed out that King County has demonstrated that they can work fairly independentlyand dotfie guality of work that the City expects at a good price. Chairman Wagner asked wha,t the total contractbeiween the two counties was in the previous year. 'fraffic Engineer Para answered $150,000.00. Directorpowdy spoke about the advantages of splitting the work between Pierce and King Counties, especially during a wet summer where dry days suitable for painting are limited. Page 11 of 13 Chairman Wagner asked how staff decides which streets get str'iping. Traffic Eng'ineer Para answered that he used the aerial photographs,of the Gity and chose all of the streets thathad paint on them and noted that the�e are some lowervolume roads that generally do not get . striped. Chairman Wagner suggesfed"a set of criteria 6e developed for striping. Chairman Wagner stated that he is supportive of the staff saving time and getting a better product by contracting the work to King and Pierce Counties. E. Capital Project Status Report (Gaub) Item8—CP1006�- Lakeland Hills Reservoir 6:Chairman Wagner asked if the coating inside and outside is underway. Assistant City Engineer Gaub answered that the inside coating is currently underway but outside is not because the contractor needs to install containment due to the wet weather. The containment will begin going up next week and then coating the outside will continue. Chairman Wagner asked when the reservoir will go online. Assistant City Engineer Gaub s#ated that the reservoir will probably not be online until early in 2012. Item 12—CP0916 —West Valley Highway —SR18 to W Main: Chairman Wagner stated that the treatment for the drainage ditches looks nice and asked when the s'ignal will be installed. Assistant City Engineer Gaub answered that.the signal will probably be completed in late December 2011 and that staff is currently working on completing the streetJighting. Item T4 — C207A—A Street NW Corridor—_Phase 1 : Assistant City Engineer Gaub stated that fencing has tieen removed and staff has been ___ . communicating with the Post Office and has made some suggested changes to their interior layout of their parking lot, in response to a question asked by Chairman 1Nagner. Assistant City Engineer Gaub reported that the parking stalls are still at a 90 degree angle but the drop-offbox was moved so cars would not queue up on A Street. Chairman Wagner strongly suggested that the parking stalls be at an angle and asked that staff continue to suggest that to the Post Office.. ' Assistant City Engineer Gaub stated that the contract currently does not include Gcurb to prevent left tums out of the Post Office parking lot on 3rd' Street, in response to a'question asked by Chairman Wagner. Item 25 — CP1119—Auburn Way South Corridor Improvements— Fir Street SE to Hemlock Street SE: Chairman Wagner asked if there is grant money being obligated. Assistant City Engineer Gau6 stated that there is and the Page 12 of 13 Transportation Improvement Board documents are signed along with the Muckleshoot Agreement and therefore all funds are obligated. Item 23— CP1112—2011 Sidewalk Improvement Project: Vice-Chair � Peloza asked if the sidewalk along Harvey Road is included in the project ' and noted one particular locatiorr of concem.Assistant Ciry Engineer Gaub answered that work on Harvey Road,is included in the scope of the project. Vice-Chair Peloza asked staff to IooK at the location because it may need to be an emergency repair. Item 33- C229A— BNSF/EVH Pedestrian Undercrossing; Chairman Wagner stated that he is going to ask the WSU senior civil engineering design group to design Project No: C229A next semester: F. Resolution No. 4766 (Snyder) A Resolution ofthe City Council of the City of Auburn, Washington, Authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to Execute an Exclusive Agency Lis4ing Agreement w'ith Jones Lang Lasalle#or Real Estate Brokerage Services for Certain City Owned Properties in Downtown Aubum Planning Director Snyder provided some background information regarding Resolution No. 4766. Snyder reviewed the modifications made to the agreement. A definition has been added to Section 3, for acceptabletenanUlease/purchaser. This will clarify the types of us.es that the leasing agent can bring to the City that would be satisfactory and consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. VI. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business to come before the Public Works Committee, the meeting was adjoumed at 5:34 p.m. Approved this 5th day of December, 2011. � �� � Rich Wegner R' y Chairman Public Wmks De�srtrneM ry _ Page 13 of 13